Xero vs Hnry: which suits a sole trader?
Verdict: Hnry suits a sole trader who wants their tax worked out, set aside and lodged for them, and who is happy for clients to pay into Hnry's account. On public prices it costs less than Xero plus an accountant up to about $110,000 of income, but it only lodges after 90 days of payments, its tax deductions are estimates, it has no payroll and it can't take on a company or trust. Xero suits anyone with staff, a company or trust, or plans for either, and anyone who wants their money in their own bank, but you still pay an accountant for the tax return.
Who each one suits
- Xero: businesses with staff, a company or a trust, or plans for any of these
- Hnry: sole traders who want tax set aside from each payment and their BAS and return lodged for them
Xero is accounting software. You keep your own books in it and can lodge your BAS from it. Hnry is a service for sole traders. Clients pay into a Hnry Account, Hnry takes out tax and its fee, and its accountants lodge your BAS and tax return.
I used my AI review agent to go through who does the tax, what each costs and where each one stops, then checked the key differences myself. Everything came from the two companies' public websites and agreements, published accountant fees and user reviews, read on 31 October 2026. Xero's prices are its regular monthly prices.
Who does the tax
With Hnry, its accountants prepare and lodge both your BAS and your income tax return, and you review and approve them. With Xero you keep the books and can lodge the BAS yourself, but as far as Xero's website shows, nothing in it lodges your income tax return. Hnry's fee includes the accountant, while on Xero you pay one separately or do the return yourself through myTax.
Hnry's tax returns page says it's a registered tax agent, but lodging isn't included from your first day. Its service agreement says it lodges "only after" you've been regularly paid into a Hnry Account for 90 consecutive days, or paid a one-off lodgement fee. Its end-of-year guide adds that you need to be paid through Hnry before 30 June, and catching up an earlier year's return costs around $300 per return.
(enlarge)
(enlarge)The tax Hnry takes out of each payment is an estimate. The agreement says Hnry can "determine and adjust without notice" the rates it deducts, and that the rates are estimated from the information you give it.
(enlarge)Clause 7.3 of the agreement limits what Hnry owes if its mistake leads to a wrong tax filing. Hnry's liability is correcting the error where possible and paying compensation "up to the equivalent of the Fees paid for the affected period or service". The same clause says losses from tax penalties, interest or regulatory action aren't compensable unless they come directly from Hnry's negligence or wilful misconduct.
(enlarge)An Australian reviewer on Trustpilot wrote in March 2026 that the estimates meant overpaying "drastically" at the start of the tax year. That's one person's report, but it fits the agreement's wording.
(enlarge)Xero's BAS guide says the software "connects directly to the ATO", so you or your bookkeeper can lodge the BAS from inside Xero after reconciling the bank transactions, and then pay what you owe. Xero tracks GST and builds the BAS figures from your books. The income tax return is different. Xero Tax is headed "Tax software for accountants & bookkeepers", and Xero's self-employed page tells you to invite your accountant.
(enlarge)Business structure fit
Hnry is only for individual sole traders and has no payroll. Xero works for any business structure and includes payroll on every plan. If you might set up a company or trust, Hnry can't come with you and you'd have to move systems later.
Clause 8.6 of Hnry's agreement, headed "Forced Termination", lets Hnry end the service "with immediate effect" if you're not "earning income as a sole-trader, freelancer or contractor".
(enlarge)Hnry doesn't ban staff, but its features menu lists 11 items and none of them is payroll, Single Touch Payroll or super for employees. An employee would mean separate payroll software.
(enlarge)Xero's plan cards show payroll for 1 person on Ignite, 2 on Grow and 5 on Comprehensive, with the Ultimate plans covering 10, 20 or 50. Its payroll reports to the ATO through Single Touch Payroll each payday and pays super from inside Xero. It doesn't work out which award applies or what rates to pay. Its payroll FAQ sends award questions to "a payroll specialist or the Fair Work Ombudsman", so checking rates against the Fair Work Ombudsman stays with you.
(enlarge)Total yearly cost
On public prices Hnry costs less than Xero plus an accountant at low and middle incomes, and the two draw level at about $110,000. Comparing Xero's monthly price with Hnry's 1% is misleading, because Xero's price leaves out the accountant. The answer depends mostly on which Xero plan you need and whether your accountant includes the quarterly BAS.
Hnry charges 1% of every payment into the Hnry Account, capped at around $1,500 a year, with BAS and tax return lodging included once the 90-day condition is met. Xero's Ignite plan is around $34 a month and Grow just over $70, with no accountant included.
Three accounting firms publish prices for a sole trader:
| Firm | Tax return only | If registered for GST |
|---|---|---|
| Sleek | $299 | from $549 |
| ReturnTax | $330 | $440 |
| Nebula Accounting | from $390 | from $690, quarterly BAS included |
(enlarge)The yearly table uses these prices. At $30,000, most sole traders are under the $75,000 GST registration threshold, so the accountant only does the return. At $80,000 and $150,000 the Xero figures use Nebula's price with the quarterly BAS.
Yearly cost before GST
| Income | Hnry | Xero Ignite + accountant | Xero Grow + accountant |
|---|---|---|---|
| $30,000 | $300 | $700 to $800 | $1,150 to $1,250 |
| $80,000 | $800 | about $1,100 | about $1,540 |
| $150,000 | $1,500 | about $1,100 | about $1,540 |
At $80,000, Hnry is about $300 a year cheaper than Ignite plus an accountant and about half the cost of Grow plus an accountant. Hnry's 1% matches Ignite plus an accountant at about $110,000. At $150,000, Hnry's cap costs about $400 more than Ignite plus an accountant and about the same as Grow plus an accountant. These are rough sums from public prices, and accountant fees vary a lot between firms.
Ignite suits a business with few invoices. It stops at 20 invoices a month on the Ignite page and at 5 bills in the plan comparison, and a footnote says invoices raised by connected apps can count towards the invoice limit. More than that means Grow, which costs just over twice as much, and then Hnry stays cheaper until close to $150,000.
(enlarge)
(enlarge)Hnry's 1% isn't the whole cost either. Its pricing page says "We've never raised our prices", but its payments page also lists a card processing fee of 1.45% (minimum 25 cents) that it shows as applying from 4 October 2026. Hnry announced the same card terms in 2022, so the rate isn't new. The agreement sets a minimum fee of 50 cents on payments under $50. The table leaves out card fees for both products.
(enlarge)Money flowing through Hnry
Hnry only works if all your self-employed income goes into its account, paid in by your clients. It takes out the tax and its fee, then passes the rest to your bank. That means tax is set aside from each payment, but every client needs new payment details, you wait an extra step to be paid and you have less control of your cash. With Xero the money lands in your own bank, and setting tax aside is up to you.
Hnry's agreement says self-employed income "that is not processed via the Hnry Account is a breach of the Service Agreement". Wages from a regular job aren't covered by this rule.
(enlarge)Clients must pay into the account directly. Moving money in from your own bank account isn't allowed unless Hnry agrees.
(enlarge)Hnry's tax payments FAQ says payouts follow "standard bank processing times", your first payment is held for identity checks, and same-day payouts cost 50 cents each.
(enlarge)If a payout gets stuck, Hnry's support answers messages in the app from 9am to 5pm AET on weekdays, not on public holidays. The page doesn't say which states' public holidays it follows.
(enlarge)When an Australian reviewer complained on Trustpilot in October 2026 about a slow payout, Hnry replied that the client had paid on a Friday afternoon before a public holiday weekend, and that its support team works Monday to Friday. Money sent before a long weekend can wait until the next working day.
(enlarge)Xero pulls in transactions from your own bank through bank feeds and takes card and direct debit payments through Stripe and GoCardless. Nothing in its plan feature table appears to set tax aside for you, so without your own set-aside the BAS and tax bill can be larger than the cash you have on hand.
(enlarge)Depth and room to grow
Hnry is deliberately simple. It covers invoices, unlimited quotes, expenses and tax for one person, which saves time if that's all your work involves. Xero adds supplier bills, stock, purchase orders, more than one currency, project costing and job apps for trades, with some of those only on the dearer plans.
A 2023 Hnry help article says that if you need "Staff & Payroll", "Inventory", "Creditors" or investors, "the Hnry service will not be suitable for you unfortunately".
(enlarge)Hnry's payments page says you can "integrate" with Stripe, PayPal, Shopify, Upwork, Mabel and Tradify. From the wording, this appears to mean those platforms pay their payouts into your Hnry Account. The page doesn't say whether orders or fees come across the way they would with Xero's integrations.
(enlarge)Xero's plan comparison puts bills on every plan (5 a month on Ignite), project time and cost tracking on the Ultimate plans only, and more than one currency from Comprehensive up. The Ignite page lists inventory and purchase orders under features in every plan. Trades job apps such as ServiceM8 and Fergus connect to Xero through the Xero App Store and keep it up to date.
(enlarge)
(enlarge)Outgrowing Hnry means moving to new software. Hnry doesn't appear to publish a guide on taking your records with you, and its agreement only says records are available "upon request" for the retention period.
Pricing in AUD
| Plan | Price | Per | Includes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ignite | $37 | per month | 20 invoices and 5 bills a month; payroll for 1 person |
| Grow | $78 | per month | Unlimited invoices and bills; payroll for 2 people; expense claims for 1 user |
| Comprehensive | $107 | per month | Payroll for 5 people; expenses for 5 users; 90-day cash flow forecast; up to 10 online bill payments |
| Ultimate 10 | $143 | per month | Payroll for 10 people; projects for 10 users; KPI analysis; 180-day forecast; 15 online bill payments |
| Ultimate 20 | $180 | per month | Payroll for 20 people |
| Ultimate 50 | $250 | per month | Payroll for 50 people |
AUD, inc GST unless marked ex GST or GST not stated. Checked 22 Oct 2026. Source: xero.com/au/versus/quickbooks-alternative, xero.com/au/pricing-plans
| Plan | Price | Per | Includes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hnry fee (yearly cap) | $1,500 ex GST | per year | 1% of each payment up to the cap; BAS and income tax return lodged once paid through Hnry for 90 consecutive days; unlimited invoices and quotes; card payments cost an extra 1.45% from 4 October 2026 |
| Earlier-year tax return | $300 ex GST | one-off | Per outstanding prior-year return |
| Same-day payout | $0.50 ex GST | one-off | Per Pay Summary paid out the same day |
AUD, inc GST unless marked ex GST or GST not stated. Checked 31 Oct 2026. Source: hnry.com.au/pricing, hnry.com.au/resources/tax-101/end-of-the-financial-year, hnry.com.au/product/tax-payments
Integrations
| Connects to | What syncs | Direction | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| ServiceM8 | Approved invoices raised in Xero; clients, items and payments sync | Both ways | |
| Stripe | Card payments on invoices | Not stated | |
| GoCardless | Direct debit payments on invoices | Not stated |
| Connects to | What syncs | Direction | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe | Payouts paid into the Hnry Account | Stripe → Hnry | |
| PayPal | Payouts paid into the Hnry Account | PayPal → Hnry | |
| Shopify | Payouts paid into the Hnry Account | Shopify → Hnry | |
| Tradify | Payments paid into the Hnry Account | Tradify → Hnry |
What I didn't test (8 things)
- Neither product was signed up for, so no BAS was prepared in Xero's demo company and Hnry's app wasn't used.
- Real Hnry payment splits and payout times, which need an account with real client income.
- The amounts in Hnry's Fee Schedule for late or amended lodgements, which are only visible inside an account.
- How to export your records from Hnry to other software, because no public page explains it.
- Where each company stores your data.
- Which public-holiday calendar Hnry's support follows, because its support page doesn't say.
- The mobile apps on a phone.
- Reddit and Whirlpool discussions, which couldn't be read during the research.
Video transcript
Introduction
Today we're looking at Xero and Hnry. Xero is accounting software where you keep your own books and lodge your BAS from it. Hnry is an accounting service for sole traders. Clients pay into a Hnry account, it takes the tax out, and its accountants lodge your returns. If you're a sole trader who wants the tax done for you, I'd start with Hnry. If you have staff or a company, or want your money in your own bank, I'd choose Xero and pay an accountant as well, or do your own return through myTax if you're a sole trader. I used my AI review agent to go through who does the tax, what each really costs and where each one stops, then checked the key differences myself.
Who does the tax
To start with, who does the tax. Hnry's accountants prepare and lodge your BAS and your income tax return for you to approve, and the tax comes out of each payment as it arrives. With Xero, you keep the books, it builds the BAS from them, and you lodge it yourself.
Who does the tax
Hnry lodges your BAS and return only after 90 days of regular payments through your Hnry account, or you pay a one-off fee. Join within about six weeks of 30 June and the fee can apply to that year's return. Catching up an earlier year's return costs $300 each.
Who does the tax
The tax Hnry takes out along the way is an estimate. Its agreement says it can change the rates without notice, that they're based on what you tell it, and that it isn't responsible for their accuracy if your information is incomplete. If Hnry makes a filing mistake, it will fix it where it can, but what it pays you is limited to the fees for that period. One reviewer reports overpaying a lot early in the tax year because of the estimates.
Who does the tax
Xero connects directly to the ATO, so you can lodge the BAS yourself. You match up your bank transactions and check the figures first, and you pay what you owe separately. Xero's tax product is for accountants and bookkeepers, and its self-employed page tells you to invite your accountant. So you'd still pay an accountant for your return, or do it yourself through myTax.
Business structure fit
Next, business structure. Hnry is only for individual sole traders. It can end your service straight away if you're no longer earning as a sole trader, freelancer or contractor. It has no payroll or employee super either, so taking on even one apprentice would mean separate payroll software.
Business structure fit
Xero isn't limited to one kind of business, and payroll is included on every plan, from one person on Ignite to much bigger teams on the top plans. It reports to the ATO each payday and pays super from inside Xero. It doesn't work out award rates for you, though, and points award questions to a payroll specialist or the Fair Work Ombudsman.
Total yearly cost
Next up, what each costs in a year. Hnry charges 1% of every payment, capped at $1,500 a year, with lodging your BAS and tax return included. Before GST, Xero's Ignite plan is about $34 a month and Grow about $71, and you'd pay an accountant on top. Three accounting firms publish their prices for a sole trader's tax return. For the return only, Sleek and ReturnTax charge about $300, and Nebula Accounting starts from $390. With a BAS the prices go up. Nebula is from $690 with the quarterly BAS included, and Sleek starts at $549 but says BAS preparation is often priced separately.
Total yearly cost
Put together, Hnry is cheaper at lower incomes. At $30,000 of income Hnry's 1% comes to $300, against $700 to $800 for Xero's Ignite plan and an accountant. At $80,000, using Nebula's price with the BAS, Hnry is about $300 cheaper than Ignite plus an accountant, and about half the cost of Grow plus an accountant. At $150,000 Hnry reaches its cap, which is about level with Grow plus an accountant and dearer than Ignite. These are rough sums from public prices, and accountant fees vary a lot.
Total yearly cost
Ignite only holds up if 20 invoices and 5 bills a month is enough, and invoices raised by connected apps count towards that. A busier sole trader gets pushed onto Grow, which costs just over twice as much. Hnry's 1% isn't the whole cost either. Card payments carry an extra 1.45%, and a payment under $50 costs at least 50 cents.
Money flowing through Hnry
Moving on to where your money goes. Hnry only works if all your self-employed income goes into its account. It takes out the tax and its fee, then sends the rest to your bank. Income that doesn't go through Hnry breaks the agreement, and clients have to pay in directly, not from your own bank account. Wages from a regular job are left out of that rule.
Money flowing through Hnry
Payouts follow normal bank processing times, your first payment is held for identity checks, and same-day payouts cost 50 cents each. You can message Hnry's team in the app or ring them on weekdays, but they only answer during business hours on working days, and in one Trustpilot case Hnry put a slow payout down to it being sent on the Friday before a public holiday weekend. Xero's support is online at any hour, and it can call you back.
Money flowing through Hnry
With Xero, the money stays in your own bank, and Xero brings in the transactions from there. Nothing in its feature list appears to set tax aside, so that's up to you, or the BAS and tax bill can catch you short.
Depth and room to grow
Finally, room to grow. Hnry keeps things simple, with invoicing, expenses and tax for one person. Its links with Stripe, PayPal, Shopify and Tradify appear to just mean those platforms pay into your Hnry account.
Depth and room to grow
Xero goes further. Project time and cost tracking is on its Ultimate plans, and more than one currency from Comprehensive up. Supplier bills are on every plan. Job apps for trades, such as ServiceM8, connect to it too.
Who each one suits
If you're a sole trader who wants your tax worked out, set aside and lodged for you, and you're happy for clients to pay into Hnry's account, I'd start with Hnry. It's cheaper than Xero plus an accountant up to about $110,000 of income. Above that, Xero's Ignite plan plus an accountant can cost less, as long as 20 invoices and 5 bills a month is enough for you. Before joining Hnry, I'd check when my first client payment would land in it, because the lodging waits on that. I'd choose Xero if you have staff, a company or trust, or might soon, or you'd rather keep your money in your own bank. Just expect to pay an accountant for your tax return as well, or do it yourself through myTax. I hope that helps you choose between these two ways of handling your books and tax.