Connecteam vs Deputy: which is better for rostering?

Comparison · Tested and prices checked · Visit Deputy · Visit Connecteam

Verdict: Deputy suits cafés, shops and other shift businesses paying staff under a modern award, because it applies the rates for the awards it supports from its cheapest plan (advanced award interpretation starts at Core), bills in Australian dollars and sells its own payroll, though users rate its support, billing and Xero connection poorly. Connecteam suits small site crews of up to 10 on one roster, who get it free with forms and training included, but the owner builds every penalty rate by hand and paid plans are priced in US dollars.

Who each one suits

  • Deputy: cafés, shops and restaurants paying staff under a modern award that want award rates applied and payroll run in the same system
  • Connecteam: cleaning, building, security and other site crews of up to 10 on one roster that want rostering and clock-in free

How it was tested

My review agent put both tools through the same tests, and I verified the key differences myself. The tests used public information only, read on 27 October 2026: each vendor's Australian website, pricing page and help centre, the Apple App Store and Xero App Store listings, and Trustpilot AU. No accounts were opened, so neither product was used to cost a real shift or send one to Xero. Connecteam's US dollar prices are converted at that day's Xe mid-market rate of US$1 to A$1.42.

Who each one is built for

Deputy is built for rostered shift work in hospitality and retail. Its industries page leads with those two, and its roster screen shows wage cost alongside the shifts.

Deputy's industries grid with hospitality and retail first (enlarge)
Deputy's industries page leads with hospitality and retail.

Connecteam is built mainly for crews working away from a base. Its industries menu starts with construction and cleaning, and also lists healthcare, food and beverage, retail, field services and security. Its App Store screenshots show GPS clock-in, cleaning checklists and safety quizzes.

Connecteam's industries menu listing construction, cleaning, field services and security (enlarge)
Connecteam's industries menu leads with site-based work such as construction and cleaning.
Connecteam Deputy
Award rates Owner enters each multiplier Basic award interpretation from Lite, advanced from Core
Payroll Sends timesheets to payroll software Own payroll add-on
Accounting software listed Xero, MYOB, QuickBooks Xero, MYOB, QuickBooks, Reckon
Pricing US dollars, flat fee per hub for up to 30 users Australian dollars per user, monthly minimum of about $30
Free plan Up to 10 users None
Free trial 14 days, no card Up to 31 days, no card
Data location Netherlands, Ireland and Germany Not found on its public pages

Connecteam has an Australian company, Connecteam AUS Pty Ltd, but its subprocessor list puts its data on Microsoft Azure in the Netherlands, with backup in Ireland, and on AWS in Germany. No Australian hosting region is listed, which matters to a business whose clients or contracts require data held in Australia. The same page lists support providers in the Philippines, Guatemala and Cyprus.

What it costs at 3, 8 and 15 staff

For three users who want their hours in Xero, Deputy is cheaper. From about eight users, Connecteam's flat fee costs less, as long as its Basic plan covers what you need. These are monthly billing, before GST:

Users Deputy Lite Deputy Core Connecteam free plan Connecteam Basic Connecteam Advanced
3 about $30 about $30 $0 about A$50 about A$85
8 about $60 about $80 $0 about A$50 about A$85
15 about $115 about $145 Over the 10-user limit about A$50 about A$85

Connecteam's figures are for its Operations hub (rostering and the time clock), converted from US dollars, and its free plan doesn't send hours to payroll software.

Deputy charges per user per month in Australian dollars, at under $10 a user on Lite and Core. Its pricing FAQ sets a minimum of about $30 per invoice on monthly plans, so three users pay the same on Lite or Core. Admins and managers count as users, so the owner and any supervisors are in the count, and anyone added, archived or unarchived is charged for the full month. Annual billing is about 10% cheaper, but an annual plan can't be downgraded or refunded. Deputy Payroll adds about $5 a user.

Connecteam's Australian pricing page shows US dollars only and doesn't say whether GST is included.

Connecteam's Australian pricing page with prices in US dollars (enlarge)
Connecteam's Australian site lists its plan prices in US dollars.

Connecteam sells its paid plans per hub. The Operations hub is one flat monthly fee for the first 30 users: around A$40 to A$50 for Basic and A$70 to A$85 for Advanced, depending on yearly or monthly billing. In the pricing table, setting a different pay rate for each person only appears from Advanced, so a business with staff on different rates should expect the higher figure.

The free Small Business plan covers up to 10 users, but the pricing table lists Payroll Integration as not included.

Connecteam's pricing table showing Payroll Integration not included on the free plan (enlarge)
Connecteam's free plan doesn't include the payroll integration that sends hours to Xero or MYOB.

Connecteam's help centre lists one job schedule on the free plan, six on Advanced and twelve on Expert. That limits the number of rosters rather than people: ten staff can share one schedule, but separate rosters for two sites need Advanced. The help centre contradicts itself on former staff. The free plan FAQ says archived users count toward the 10 seats, while a newer article on archiving and deleting users says only active users count and that archiving needs Advanced. Deleting a former staff member frees the seat but wipes their records.

Sunday, public holiday and overtime rates

Deputy applies the rates for the modern awards it supports, such as Hospitality and General Retail, though some conditions are still manual, while Connecteam leaves the owner to build each rate.

Deputy lists basic award interpretation on its cheapest plan, Lite, and advanced award interpretation from Core.

Deputy's Lite plan card listing Award Interpretation (enlarge)
Basic award interpretation is included from Deputy's cheapest plan.

Its award page names the awards it covers, including Hospitality (MA000009) and General Retail (MA000004).

Deputy's award page naming the Hospitality and General Retail awards (enlarge)
Deputy names the modern awards its rules are built on.

Its Hospitality rules apply the Sunday rate only when no other condition is met, so a public holiday that falls on a Sunday is paid at the public holiday rate.

Deputy's Hospitality award rules for Sunday and public holiday rates (enlarge)
Deputy's Hospitality rules pay the public holiday rate when a public holiday falls on a Sunday.

Deputy's help article also lists what its award rules leave to the owner. Leave loading is added to timesheets by hand, loaded rates aren't supported, overnight-stay penalties are manual, hours aren't averaged over multi-week rosters, and penalty rates apply in full-hour blocks only. The article says the pay engine isn't legal or payroll advice.

Deputy's list of award conditions its rules don't handle (enlarge)
Deputy's award rules leave leave loading and part-hour penalties to the owner.

Connecteam's Australian pay rules article never mentions modern awards or Fair Work. It gives generic multipliers for Saturday, Sunday, public holidays and overtime, and each one is set up by hand. That works if you know your award's rates and enter each one correctly.

Connecteam's table of generic weekend and public holiday multipliers with no award named (enlarge)
Connecteam's Australian pay rules use generic multipliers and name no award.

Connecteam's own public holiday example gets the rate wrong. The heading says 2.5x, but the steps say to add an extra 2.5x on top of the base wage, and the article's example gives $35 an hour on a $10 base, which is 3.5x. The same article's Saturday example shows an Additional Rate of 0.5x paying 1.5x in total, so a 2.5x public holiday needs an Additional Rate of 1.5x.

Connecteam's 2.5x public holiday heading above steps that pay $35 on a $10 base (enlarge)
Following Connecteam's public holiday steps pays 3.5 times the base rate, not 2.5.

Forms, training and a staff handbook

These tools are Connecteam's main advantage for a crew on site. Its forms and checklists take photos and signatures and record where each one was filled in.

Connecteam's forms with location-verified submissions, photos and signatures (enlarge)
Connecteam's forms record photos, signatures and the location of each submission.

Training courses track who has finished, and the staff handbook and policies sit in a knowledge base on each person's phone. The free plan includes all of this for up to 10 users. On a paid plan, Connecteam sells its Operations, Communications, and HR & Skills hubs as separate subscriptions. The Communications and HR hubs each have a free Limited plan with a basic knowledge base and a few courses, but the fuller training and handbook tools are priced separately from rostering and the time clock.

Connecteam's hub tabs for Operations, Communications, and HR & Skills (enlarge)
Each Connecteam hub is a separate subscription on a paid plan.

Getting hours into payroll and Xero

Deputy can run the payroll itself, while Connecteam sends timesheets to your payroll software. Deputy's Xero export depends on exact matching between the two systems, while Connecteam's Xero guide recommends identical names but lets you match employees by hand when they differ.

Deputy Payroll is an add-on that can pay more than one business from one account. Its setup video is built around Australian details such as ABN, super fund and pay calendars, and Deputy says it is "designed to support Single Touch Payroll Phase 2".

Deputy's payroll setup video transcript covering ABN, super fund and pay calendars (enlarge)
Deputy's payroll setup is built around Australian payroll details.

For businesses that stay on Xero Payroll, Deputy's pre-export checklist needs identical names and emails in both systems, pay rates on each employee's Xero pay template, a payroll calendar, and a draft Xero pay run with dates that exactly match the export. Award rates only carry over if the Xero pay items are named in the format set out in Deputy's guide to award interpretation with Xero.

Deputy's checklist of conditions before exporting timesheets to Xero (enlarge)
Deputy's Xero export needs names, pay rates and pay run dates to match exactly.

Deputy's Xero App Store listing rates 3.9 from 148 reviews.

Deputy rated 3.9 from 148 reviews on the Xero App Store (enlarge)
Xero users rate Deputy's connection 3.9.

Several of the low reviews there are about getting the connection working.

Connecteam's Xero listing rates 4.7 from 50 reviews. It says regular hours, leave, and daily and weekly overtime can be transferred. Saturday, Sunday and public holiday rules built as Additional Rates aren't on that list, but Connecteam's Xero help article says exported pay rules are split into weekdays, Saturdays, Sundays and public holidays, or by job, and each is matched to its own Xero earnings rate. Connecteam lists Xero, MYOB and QuickBooks but not Reckon, while Deputy lists all four.

Support and billing

Users rate both phone apps 4.8 on the Australian App Store, from about 5,500 ratings for Connecteam and 8,200 for Deputy. On Trustpilot AU, Connecteam rates 4.7 from 1,914 reviews and Deputy 2.7 from 135. Deputy's recent low reviews report slow support passed from one rep to another, and being charged for staff who had left or after cancelling. Connecteam's few low reviews are mostly about chat-only support and paying for "PRO" support sessions.

Both companies advertise 24/7 support. Neither publishes Australian business hours. Deputy's Australian homepage lists a Sydney phone number, which may be for sales, while Connecteam's Australian site offers a message form and no phone number.

Which one to start with

For a café, shop or restaurant paying staff under a modern award, I'd start with Deputy, because it applies the award rates and can run the payroll too. For a cleaning or building crew of up to ten on one roster, I'd start with Connecteam, because it's free at that size. In either trial, the first thing I'd do is cost a real Sunday shift and send it to Xero.

Pricing

Deputy plans
PlanPricePerIncludes
Lite (monthly billing)$7.50 ex GSTper user per monthBasic rostering, timesheets, time clock and basic award interpretation. $30 minimum per invoice on monthly plans; admins and managers count as users.
Lite (annual billing)$6.75 ex GSTper user per monthAs Lite monthly; 12-month term, no refund or headcount reduction if cancelled early
Core (monthly billing)$9.75 ex GSTper user per monthAdds advanced rostering, timesheet auto-approval, biometric clocking and advanced award interpretation. $30 minimum per invoice.
Core (annual billing)$8.75 ex GSTper user per monthAs Core monthly; 12-month term, no refund if cancelled early
Pro (monthly billing)$14.50 ex GSTper user per monthAdds custom access levels, location hierarchies and pay centres. Contact sales.
Pro (annual billing)$13 ex GSTper user per monthAs Pro monthly; 12-month term
All-in-One bundle$13.95 ex GSTper user per monthRostering plus HR and Payroll. Shown against $16.40; appears to be the annual-billing price.
Payroll add-on$5 ex GSTper user per monthDeputy Payroll, which Deputy says is designed to support STP Phase 2; 30-day trial

AUD, inc GST unless marked ex GST or GST not stated. Checked 27 Oct 2026. Source: deputy.com/au/pricing

Connecteam plans
PlanPricePerIncludes
Small Business (free)FreeUp to 10 users, all hubs. Help centre lists one job schedule. Payroll Integration not included.
Operations Basic (monthly billing)US$35 ex taxper monthUS$35 a month flat for the first 30 users, about A$50 at US$1 = A$1.4232 (Xe, 27 Oct 2026); US$1.00 per extra user
Operations Basic (yearly billing)US$29 ex taxper monthUS$29 a month billed yearly for the first 30 users, about A$41; US$0.80 per extra user
Operations Advanced (monthly billing)US$59 ex taxper monthUS$59 a month flat for the first 30 users, about A$84; adds per-person pay rates and six job schedules; US$3.00 per extra user
Operations Advanced (yearly billing)US$49 ex taxper monthUS$49 a month billed yearly for the first 30 users, about A$70; US$2.50 per extra user
Operations Expert (monthly billing)US$119 ex taxper monthUS$119 a month flat for the first 30 users; twelve job schedules; US$5.00 per extra user
Operations Expert (yearly billing)US$99 ex taxper monthUS$99 a month billed yearly for the first 30 users, about A$141; US$4.20 per extra user

Connecteam charges in US dollars. Your bank converts the price and may charge a foreign transaction fee. Checked 27 Oct 2026. Source: connecteam.com/pricing, au.connecteam.com/pricing

Integrations

Deputy integrations
Connects toWhat syncsDirectionChecked
XeroTimesheets exported to Xero Payroll; award rates carry over when pay items are named in Deputy's formatDeputy → Xero
MYOBNot statedNot stated
QuickBooksNot statedNot stated
ReckonNot statedNot stated
ServiceM8Not statedNot stated
Connecteam integrations
Connects toWhat syncsDirectionChecked
XeroTimesheets with regular hours, leave, and daily and weekly overtime go to Xero; pay items come back; employee records sync both waysBoth ways
MYOBNot statedNot stated
QuickBooksNot statedNot stated
What I didn't test (9 things)
  • Costing a real Sunday or public holiday shift in either product, because no accounts were opened for this comparison
  • Exporting timesheets with penalty rates to a Xero demo company, which needs accounts in both products and a Xero login
  • Hitting the free plan's limits inside Connecteam's app, or archiving and deleting users to see how the 10 seats are counted
  • Whether Connecteam's free plan is limited to one time clock: no public source was found and the pricing table's scheduling rows wouldn't expand
  • Support reply times during Australian business hours, which needs a real support request to each vendor
  • Deputy's open-shift list and Connecteam's first-day notifications in the phone apps, which need the apps on a phone
  • Where Deputy keeps its data: its subprocessor page came back empty and no public page says
  • Ratings on Google Play, Capterra, G2 and TrustRadius, which were blocked or wouldn't load
  • Other Australian rostering products, which weren't researched for this comparison
Video transcript

Connecteam and Deputy

Today we're looking at Connecteam and Deputy, two staff scheduling apps that handle your rosters, clocking on and off, and timesheets. Connecteam is built for crews out on sites, and Deputy for shift work in cafés and shops. My review agent compared them side by side, and I verified the key differences myself. If you pay staff under a modern award, I'd start with Deputy, though its users rate its support poorly. For a small crew on one roster, I'd start with Connecteam, but you set up every pay rate yourself and pay in US dollars.

Key features side by side

Side by side, the biggest difference is pay. Deputy says it works out award rates for you, and it sells its own payroll, while Connecteam has you set up your own pay rules and send timesheets to your payroll software. Connecteam has more for crews out in the field, such as forms, checklists and training courses. Deputy has no forms builder or built-in courses, but it keeps training records with expiry dates, and uses them to limit who can be rostered. Deputy can keep your data in Australia, while Connecteam stores it in Europe. Deputy's free trial runs longer.

What it costs

Next up, what it costs, checked in October 2026. Deputy charges per person in Australian dollars, with a thirty dollar monthly minimum, and the owner and managers count as users. Connecteam's paid rostering plan is one flat price for up to thirty users, and its free plan covers ten staff on one roster. Converted to Australian dollars, that paid plan costs more than Deputy's minimum for three staff, but by eight staff it's cheaper, and at fifteen it's less than half the price of Deputy Lite. Deputy's annual plans are cheaper than paying monthly. Connecteam refunds the unused part of an annual plan if you cancel in the first thirty days, and nothing after that.

Deputy works out award rates

Next up, Sunday, public holiday and overtime rates. Deputy includes award rules on its cheapest plan, Lite, and names the modern awards it covers, such as the Hospitality and General Retail awards. Its award rules are meant to cover Sunday and public holiday rates, so check a public holiday that falls on a Sunday in your trial. Some things are still left to the owner, such as adding leave loading by hand, and penalty rates only apply in full-hour blocks.

Connecteam: you build the pay rules

Connecteam handles these rates the other way. It doesn't know any modern award, so you build your own Sunday, public holiday and overtime rules from its set multipliers. That works if you know your award's rates and enter each one correctly. Connecteam's own public holiday example turns a ten dollar base wage into thirty-five dollars an hour, which is three and a half times the rate, not the two and a half its heading says.

Connecteam's tools for crews

Next up, Connecteam's tools for crews out on site. Its forms and checklists take photos and signatures and record where each one was filled in. There are training courses that track who's finished, and the staff handbook sits in a knowledge base on everyone's phone. On a paid plan, training and the handbook are two separate extra subscriptions on top of rostering and the time clock, each from about thirty US dollars a month.

Getting hours into payroll

Next up, getting hours into payroll. Deputy sells its own payroll for five dollars a user a month, which it says is designed to support Single Touch Payroll Phase 2. Both products also send timesheets to Xero, and both take careful setup. Deputy needs names, pay items and pay run dates to match exactly, and Connecteam's Xero setup needs much the same matching. Users on the Xero app store rate Deputy's connection 3.9, and two of its one-star reviews there report trouble getting it connected. Connecteam's rates 4.7, though sending hours to Xero needs at least its Basic plan.

What users say

Next up, what users say. Connecteam's and Deputy's phone apps both rate 4.8 on the App Store, but on Trustpilot, Connecteam averages 4.7 and Deputy 2.8, and Deputy's recent reviews complain about support and billing. Connecteam has far fewer complaints.

Who each one suits

For a café, shop or restaurant paying staff under a modern award, I'd start with Deputy, because it works out the award rates and can run the payroll too, even with its fiddly Xero setup and support that its users rate poorly. For a small cleaning or building crew of up to ten on one roster, I'd start with Connecteam, because it's free and stays one flat price as you grow. I wouldn't choose it for a business with a lot of penalty rates, because the owner builds every rate and has to get each one right. The first thing I'd try in a trial is costing a real Sunday shift and sending it to Xero. I hope that helps you choose between these two rostering apps.